Programming

RPE or Percentages: Which Should You Use?

By Devin Smith, NCSF-CPT · Precision Nutrition L1 · NASM Physique & Bodybuilding Coach · November 2026

Two ways of choosing the weight on the bar come up in almost every conversation with a new client. One is percentages: you take a tested max and work at, say, a set fraction of it. The other is RPE: you rate how hard a set felt on a scale of one to ten and adjust the weight to hit a target. Neither is better in every case. Here is how I decide, and where each one lets you down.

I'm a coach, not a medical provider. If you have a health condition, talk to your doctor before you start a new program.

How percentages work

With percentages, a program says things like "five sets of three at a given percentage of your max." You multiply, round to the plates you have and lift. The appeal is that it is clear. Nobody has to guess, and you can see the plan for the whole month at a glance.

The weak spot is the max itself. If the number you started from is out of date, every percentage after it is off. If it was a lucky day or a bad day, the same is true. And your max is not a set number from one week to the next. Sleep, stress and a long day at work move it around.

How RPE works

With RPE, the program asks for a hard-but-controlled set and you pick the weight that gets you there. A seven means a few reps were left. A nine means maybe one. Because it follows how you feel that day, it adjusts itself when you are tired or when you are moving well. If you want the full explanation of the scale, I wrote it up in how to read RPE.

The weak spot is honesty and experience. New lifters often rate a set as a nine when it was a six, because every set feels hard when the lift is new. Lifters who like to be tough often rate an eight as a six. Either way the number is only useful if it is accurate, which takes some practice and some video.

What I use for a true beginner

For someone in their first few months, I usually keep the weights simple. A set weight for each exercise, a target number of reps and a quick effort rating at the end. The rating is there to teach you what a seven feels like, not to drive the whole program. You do not have a trustworthy max yet, so percentages would be built on sand, and you do not have a trustworthy sense of effort yet, so I do not let RPE run the show either.

What I use once the lifts are steady

After a few months, I mix the two. A percentage gives a starting point for the top set. RPE is the guardrail: if that weight feels like a nine when the plan said seven, you take weight off, and if it feels like a five, you add some. That way you get the structure of numbers and the honesty of how you actually feel. Your log then shows me what the percentage really meant for you that week.

What I use as a meet gets closer

I have not competed yet, so I am not going to pretend to be a meet veteran. What I do know is how programs are built: as a meet date gets closer, loads get more specific, and numbers matter more, because you want to know what a given weight feels like at the time it counts. Percentages are useful there, with effort ratings checking them. I put the basics in peaking for a powerlifting meet.

A simple way to choose

The part that matters most

Whichever you pick, the log is what makes it work. A plan with a percentage and no record of how it felt tells you very little. A plan with an effort rating and no weights written down tells you even less. Write both: the weight and how hard it was. That pair is what I read when I coach remotely, and it is what lets me change a plan before it stalls. If your own training has stopped moving, the progression article is the place to start.

Where I fit in

In my remote coaching, I choose the method for you and explain it as we go. Core is $99 a month, Lifestyle is $169 and Full is $259. Monthly plans have a 3-month minimum from your start date. After month three, cancel any time before your next billing date. No refunds. The coaching page lays out what each includes. If you want to feel effort ratings before you commit, the free week uses them from day one.

Not sure which method fits you? Start with the free week, or book an assessment and we will pick one together.

Coaching is not medical treatment. BodySmithing does not diagnose, treat, cure, or guarantee results. If something hurts, see a clinician, and check with your doctor before starting a new exercise program.

Start the free week